Thinking about a pellet grill? Let's look at the Pros and Cons.

• Posted on 11 March 2025
• 0

Check out this comprehensive breakdown to help you decide if a pellet grill is right for your grilling and smoking needs.

One of the first big decisions when shopping for a grill is what fuel source to go with. Charcoal and gas grills have traditionally been the most prevalent options, but as pellet grills have gained in popularity over the past decade, many people are interested in exploring why they’ve gained such a strong reputation. Here, we'll take a look at the pros and cons of pellet grills and key features like temperature control, smoke flavor, and cooking method versatility.

What are Pellet Grills?

Pellet grills are versatile outdoor cooking devices that use compressed wood pellets to grill and smoke food. While the quality of wood pellets can vary, those produced by a quality manufacturer like BBQr's Delight will burn hot and efficiently and enhance food with a smooth smoke flavor. Pellets are available in a variety of hardwood flavors, each featuring distinct flavor characteristics, such as hickory, apple, mesquite, and more.

Pellet grills require access to an electrical outlet, as they feature several powered components. After you load pellets into a hopper and power your pellet grill, an auger moves them from the hopper to the fire pot or burn pot. An igniter heats the pellets while a fan moves air across the fire pot to start ignition.

The igniter rod will turn off once the pellets are burning, and the small fire will create the heat necessary to grill, smoke, and bake or roast foods. The grill’s fan system will provide a constant oxygen source that keeps the fire alive and circulates heat and smoke throughout the cooking chamber.

At the most basic level, pellet grills function as outdoor convection ovens that add a depth of flavor to food that can’t be achieved when cooking indoors. But more advanced models like the Pitts & Spitts Maverick 1250 are also capable of over-the-flame cooking, which allows you to directly grill foods at high heat. They can also be set up for multi-zone cooking, making it possible to cook multiple dishes simultaneously — and even complete meals.

Pros of Pellet Grills

So, what is it that sets pellet grills apart from gas grills and charcoal grills? It’s how they offer both cooking convenience and flavor complexity by embodying the following characteristics:

• Convenient and Precise Temperature Control: One electrical component that makes pellet grills sing is a temperature control panel that lets you set the grill to a specific temperature. You don’t have to mess with vents or tinker with the fire to hit a desired temperature. Simply dial in a set point, and the automated control system will do the rest. A quality pellet grill will offer incremental temperature points between 160°F and at least 500°F, but take a deeper look into capabilities at the higher end of that range. Many pellet grills advertise high heat points without offering the setup options to grill food over a direct flame, limiting your ability to sear or get a nice char on food.
• Consistent Smoke Flavor: Once a pellet grill reaches the desired cooking temperature, it can gradually add fuel to keep the fire going without fundamentally changing its characteristics. Adding just a few pellets at a time also keeps smoke levels consistent, adding just the right amount of flavor to food without overwhelming the profile.
• Versatility in Cooking Styles: Quality pellet grills can smoke, roast, bake, grill, and more. The most versatile models offer accessories like stainless steel griddles and wood-fired smoke boxes, which quickly and seamlessly transform a pellet grill into an all-in-one cooking machine capable of cooking just about any recipe.
• Ease of Use: The digital controllers on pellet grills make cooking more intuitive than charcoal or gas models. Some controllers can also monitor food temperature as it cooks, providing mobile alerts or even automatically adjusting the grill temperature when food reaches a pre-determined internal temperature, which is perfect for someone who has other things to do while cooking.

Cons of Pellet Grills

While pellet grills can be great, some attributes cause people to hesitate when considering which type of grill to invest in. These can include:

• High Heat Limitations: While they excel at low-and-slow cooking, pellet grills might not achieve the high heat needed for some types of grilling, like searing. However, pellet grill technology is constantly improving. As mentioned above, advanced models like the Pitts & Spitts Maverick 1250 have proven up to the task of high-heat cooking, unlike many of their peers.
• Dependence on Electricity: Since most pellet grills rely on electric power for their mechanisms, they may not be ideal for off-the-grid grilling. Anyone considering a pellet grill should ensure they have any power requirements figured out in advance where they intend to station it.
• Price: The upfront cost for pellet grills can be higher than traditional charcoal or comparable gas grills, primarily because of the technology and electrical components required to run them. Pellet grills built from construction-grade steel with fully welded assemblies will also cost a bit more, but the tradeoff is that they should come with more robust warranties and will last longer than other grills. 

Pellet Grills vs. Other Grill Options

Having explored some of the pros and cons of pellet grills, let’s examine the differentiations between pellet grills and other types of grills.

• Pellet Grills vs. Charcoal/Wood Grills: Charcoal or Wood-Fired grills can be used for grilling or smoking and add rich flavor to food. People have been cooking with charcoal and wood for centuries, making it a tried and true method for delicious cooking. However, charcoal/wood grills lack the convenience and ease of use that pellet grills offer and require significantly more hands-on management for longer cooking sessions. They have be perfect for the person who wants to slow down and enjoy the process of cooking more.
• Pellet Grills vs. Gas Grills: Gas grills are easy to use and have long been the preferred alternative to charcoal/wood grilling. They excel at direct over-the-fire cooking but lack the versatility of pellet grills, especially for indirect cooking like baking or roasting. Higher quality manufacturers like Twin Eagles, Delta Heat, Summerset and Napoleon are getting clever about how to incorporate charcoal or wood back in, but you can't expect quite the same flavor as cooking on a charcoal/wood grill. Pellet grills also excel over their gas counterparts regarding precise temperature control. Some manufacturers such as Napoleon are addressing this with specific models, but you still lack control of the grill like you would get with a pellet grill.
• Pellet Grills vs. Electric Smokers: Both pellet grills and electric smokers offer temperature precision, though the smoke quality and circulation provided by electric smokers falls well behind that of pellet grills. As a result, the flavor profile of food cooked on electric smokers tends to be thin, and they lack any kind of over-the-flame cooking capability. This is the primary reason there aren't that many available on the market today.

Common Questions About Pellet Grills

How Do Pellet Grills Work?

Pellet grills feed compressed wood pellets from a hopper into a burn pot. Once the fire is ignited, a fan circulates oxygen to the fire and circulates the heat and smoke to cook food at a precise temperature.

Do Pellet Grills Use Wood Pellets?

Yes. Pellet grills use food-grade cooking pellets — as opposed to the heating pellets made specifically for wood stoves and are not safe for cooking or consumption — that not only serve as a heat source but also add flavor to food.

How Do I Use a Pellet Grill?

Cooking on a pellet grill requires many of the same general principles as indoor cooking or cooking on other types of grills. The main idea is setting the temperature on the controller and turning it on so that it can come up to the temperature that you set in order for you to cook what you're desired item(s) happen to be.

Can I Smoke a Whole Brisket on a Pellet Grill?

The great thing about pellet grills is you can cook just about anything on them. And yes, you can use your tried and true method for smoking a brisket on your pellet smoker.

More Specific Questions We Get About Pellet Grills

What Makes One Pellet Grill Better Than Another?

The answer on this is more complicated, but the short answer is "Features"

The TLDR version of that answer involves things like built quality, materials used in building, versatility, and, believe it or not, the program that is in the controller. 

Quality

Like anything in this world, there are Good/Better/Best options for pretty much anything you may want to buy. There are different price points for different reasons, and like most things, you get what you pay for.

That doesn't mean that there isn't a point of diminishing returns, but when you reach that point and you get to splitting hairs, you can see that there is still a target market for manufacturers, and customers who are looking for those types of products. We put those into an additional category that we consider to be "Luxury". 

Materials

Made with thinner materials,  and generally a few less features , they'll usually be smaller or maybe a more portable version, the Good classification of pellet grills are going to do a good job of cooking a smaller capacity of food, they'll usually come with a pretty decent warranty, and they'll do well for you for a few years.

The Better category will have several of the industry leading features, they'll be made with upgraded materials, they'll have more features, and they'll usually have more accessory support to make them more versatile. To top it off, they usually have better warranties than the last category.

When it comes to the Best level of grills, you can expect to see a pretty substantial jump in materials, fit, and finish. These grills usually have some variant of the popular features from the previous category, just more robust in build. Lastly, the warranties you can expect to find on these pellet grills are industry leading. 

Luxury grills are in a class of their own, with fit, finish, and materials all being top notch. These pellet grills can be had as either a built-in or freestanding configuration on a cart. You're likely not going to find any compromises being made with these grills, and they are among the nicest you'll find!

Versatility

While the majority of pellet grills have a good range of temps that you can use to cook or smoke with, it's the extras that really narrow down what makes up a good product for you. With various features like heat diverters and smoke boxes, there are numerous avenues that you can go when choosing, and sometimes there are other extras like side burners, blankets, and material upgrades such as full stainless construction options. This is where we come in to help you determine what you cook, how many you cook for, if you're only cooking the proteins on the grill or cooking the entire meal. These devices can be a one trick pony, or a full-on cooking chameleon. Need help figuring it all out? Just let us know.

Program

This is one big thing that you usually can't do anything about, so it's important to know what seasoned experts have to say about these units. Seeking out people that have used them can make a big difference in buying a unit that is going to do what you want vs. getting one that you think will do what you want.
There are workarounds for the majority of cases, but you should never expect a pellet grill to put out the same amount of smokey flavor that an offset will do. We can get you close with the right grill, however.

If It Is A "Set It And Forget It" Cooking Device, What Can I Do To Influence My Food?

Temperature/Technique

The main thing to know about pellet grills is that you're working against physics. Pellet grills create fire in what's called a "firepot", and it is only about 4" in diameter in most instances. Because of this, you can generate more smoke when using your grill at lower temperatures, but higher the temperature goes, the less smoke you're able to generate. There are some tricks that you can use to improve your results, and we can help you learn more about that.

Fuel

Your fuel can be as important as the meat you're cooking. Low quality, inexpensive fuels can also cause problems with auger jams and burnback. That doesn't mean you have to spend exorbitant amounts on fuels, it's just important to keep in mind where it's coming from and how it's made. We carry BBQr's Delight because they are high-quality, 100% hardwood pellets that we keep in a climate controlled area so as not to introduce any unnecessary moisture before you buy it.

Choose A Pellet Grill That Has A Good Program From The Start

We constantly hear customers talk about "not getting any smoke" from the grill they have. We strongly believe that the grill brands we carry are among the best in the industry. They offer programs that do a good job laying smoke on with their programs, and they offer the highest reliability. 

In the end, whether or not a pellet grill is the right choice for you depends on your individual grilling needs and aspirations. Pellet grills excel in versatility and ease of use, so regardless of your current cooking experience, be assured that they are simple enough for beginners to use and versatile enough for seasoned outdoor cooks.

After considering those factors, make sure to check out The Grill Guys' selection of pellet grills and our vast library of recipes and cooking tips to get a better idea of the many different cooking options pellet grills offer.